There’s a simple but powerful truth about human behaviour that every finance professional should understand.
It’s called the decision paradox.
Here’s how it works:
When people have too few choices, they resist because they feel trapped.
When they have too many choices, they resist again because they feel overwhelmed.
Either way, the outcome is the same: Resistance.
Why Recommendations Can Backfire
In finance, we often think influence means presenting a strong recommendation: “This is what I think we should do.”
It sounds decisive. It feels professional. But psychologically, it can backfire.
Because when you give someone a single recommendation, you’ve taken away their sense of choice. And when people lose choice, they lose ownership. Without ownership, there’s no commitment.
Give People Control
If you want to influence decisions, don’t tell people what to do help them decide.
The key is to frame the conversation around options, not instructions. Let them feel in control of the outcome, even if you’ve helped shape it.
That’s how influence really works.
And research and experience both point to the same number:
Three options.Not one. Not five. Three.
Three creates enough variety to feel like choice, but enough focus to prevent overwhelm.
The FBP Approach
Next time you’re preparing for a discussion with a stakeholder or presenting a business case, don’t lead with a recommendation. Instead, say something like:
“There are three ways we could approach this.”
“Option one does X…”
“Option two does Y…”
“Option three does Z…”
Then pause. Let them think.
Ask, “Which one feels right to you?”
They’ll take ownership of the decision — and you’ll have shaped it.
The Real Pro Tip
The best influencers don’t care which option the other person chooses. They care that a decision gets made, and that the person making it feels confident, informed, and in control.
That’s how you move from presenting numbers to shaping outcomes.